Cameronbridge Grain 2022 Q2: 15 LPA @ £1.02 per LPA
Sold at 10:42:05 BST

Wine investment versus whisky investing

Comparison of whisky and wine investing

Although different in taste and alcohol content, wine and whisky share some similarities during their production and maturation processes and many similarities in the way each has become an investable asset.

There are several ways in which private investors can directly and indirectly gain exposure to the potential profits within the wine and whisky drink sector.

How to invest in wine and whisky

Investment routeWineWhisky
Vineyard and distillery ownershipBuy a vineyard or winery.

Saint-Emilion vineyard for sale for €10.6 million
Buy an old distillery or build a new one.

Ardnahoe recently opened and cost £12 million
Stocks & sharesPernod Ricard owns some of the world’s best-known wine brands and whisky brands.

EPA: RI
Diageo is the largest company in the Scotch whisky industry.

LON: DGE
Prior to bottlingEn Primeur – wine purchased prior to bottling and excluding VAT and Duty. Delivery can take a few years and may also trigger the payment of VAT & Duty.

Storing investment wine under bond makes it simpler to sell at a later date and also defers the payment of VAT & Duty.

Weather significantly impacts grape harvests and it is not known whether a particular year will be a standout vintage until it has been bottled and tested. Therefore, buying En Primeur always includes an element of the unknown.
Maturing casks of whisky. Purchase the entire cask or simply the maturing whisky within each barrel. Duty & VAT are only payable once the whisky has been bottled.

Where there is a live and transparent market such as WhiskyInvestDirect, whisky in bonded storage can easily be traded prior to bottling.

For individual cask owners the process of finding competitive storage rates and an industry buyer willing to pay market prices for a couple of hundred LPA is likely to be long and drawn out.
AuctionsOne way to achieve maximum value for a rare or highly desirable wine. However, if wine is not stored in optimal conditions, it can deteriorate over time. Hence rare or highly regarded wines that achieve headline prices undoubtedly come with proof of prior ownership and storage.Fortunately, whisky does not change within a sealed bottle and consequently does not require temperature-controlled storage. Unlike wine, however, it should be stored upright.

The recent rise in interest in whisky as an investment has also seen many headlines surrounding cheap whisky in expensive fake bottles.

Why invest in wine or whisky?

Some investors have a passion for wine or whisky, and their deep knowledge provides an advantage when evaluating different grape varieties, terroir, Chateau, vintages, Distilleries, regions and casks.

Most investors in wine and whisky are unlikely to have the same detailed level of knowledge as an industry insider or the experienced investor. But this should not preclude private investors from taking a look at these alternative physical asset investments.

Before proceeding with a whisky or wine investment, there are a few key points to understand and look out for.

Ownership

When investing in physical assets such as wine or whisky held at arm's length, it is essential that your ownership is proven, and that the investment asset is not recorded as anyone else's asset. Check that it doesn't appear on your provider's own business balance sheet. A reputable investment provider should regularly provide a third-party statement, showing all holdings and proving investor ownership.

Storage

Investors should expect to pay storage fees for their wines and whiskies, because specialist bonded warehousing is not free. In fact, payment of such fees has been decisive in proving ownership in law in the past. These charges could impact the profitability of your investment, so the lower the monthly storage fees the better. The storage provider must also satisfy all HMRC requirements and assist in organising any Duty and VAT payments due as bottles leave bonded storage.

Selling should always be as easy as buying

Before buying any investment asset it is critical to understand how quickly the investment can be sold, the costs involved and the speed with which funds are returned. A reputable investment service provider should welcome clients testing their procedures for selling and withdrawing funds.

Please note in an auction there is unlikely to be a deep pool of liquidity and realising investment gains may take longer than expected.

How to spot a scam

There have been several financial scams in recent years with authorities seemingly unable to keep pace with the fraudsters. WhiskyInvestDirect’s sister business BullionVault provides a useful article explaining the 7 signs of an investment scam.

Tax

One reason for the growing interest in whisky and wine as alternative investments is the way they can be presented to UK tax authorities as a wasting asset – that is, an asset with a predictable life of 50 years or less. These wasting assets are with some exceptions generally free from UK Capital Gain Tax (CGT).

Comparing wine and whisky production

Production processWineWhisky
Raw ingredientsGrapes (multiple varieties of red & white grape).Cereals (malted barley, wheat and corn are the most commonly used).
FermentationGrapes are mechanically pressed, usually with seeds and skins removed from white wine and retained for red. Adding yeast starts fermentation, when complete and after filtering the wine is transferred to tanks or barrels to start the ageing process.Cereals germinate releasing enzymes turning grain starch into sugars. Yeast then added for fermentation resulting in a sugary mixture called ‘wash’ which is essentially beer.
DistillationWine is not distilled.The wash is then distilled in large copper pot stills, or in a continuous still, with design and shape intended to create different flavours and character.
Alcohol % prior to ageingAlcohol by volume (ABV) average ~11.6%.Alcohol by volume (ABV) average ~70-90%.
Ageing vesselsStainless steel tanks, oak casks and bottles.Oak casks of varying sizes previously holding other wines, beers or spirits.
Ageing processWine can begin ageing in many different vessels before finally ageing in the bottle.Whisky ages in a cask. Whilst maturing whiskies ABV reduces. Once bottled whisky does not age.
Spoiling or going badWine can age beyond its prime, and it can also be contaminated during the production process or whilst ageing. The result is known as a “corked” wine. Corks can also fail and allow air to spoil the wine.Whisky may mature in a cask that doesn’t provide quite as much flavour as the next cask but doesn’t actually go bad.

Whisky does not change once it is in the bottle.
Scotch whisky insights: Dr Alan Rutherford

Start trading for free

Receive one complimentary LPA on signup and test buying and selling before you commit your own money.

Open account

Open your account in two minutes

Start trading with one complimentary LPA
Open your account